Investment and Economic Review - SMSF - MDA - SMA - Sydney - Melbourne
Privacy Policy · Disclaimer · FSG
F Palmer & ME Palmer
Trading as Joseph Palmer & Sons
AFS Licence 247067 · ABN 29 548 490 818

Palmer Articles

No articles found with the specified search parameters. Return

Investment & Economic Review January 2021

27 Jan 2021

Financial market observers, investors and analysts can be forgiven for being perplexed, as longstanding and normal logic was disregarded in the second half of 2020 – remarkably, share and real estate prices actually rose despite the recession, depressed earnings, global pandemic and political turbulence.

There are multiple explanations for the quick recovery in asset prices. Firstly, the cause of the financial market downturn was extraneous, so the economic effect is likely to be relatively short, rather than a drawn-out recession. Secondly, governments and central banks have been extraordinarily accommodating, taking the view that society needed an almost unlimited supply of financial support, to be delivered with haste. Thirdly, the pandemic has caused or accelerated some economic and sectoral trends, the effect of which has resulted in the business conditions in some sectors to have improved in 2020, whilst others have slumped.

In Australia, the Federal Government, and their agency the Reserve Bank have come to the rescue. When the 2020 chapter is inserted in history books, as it indubitably will, some reference will be made to the gigantic increase in Australia indebtedness, and the abandonment of any pretense of balancing budgets, and this by a Liberal government, whose core philosophies have been scrapped.

A trillion dollars are being borrowed in Australia, but at least the financial conditions for doing so are perfect. Inflation has been kept at bay for decades, due partly to the disinflationary effects of globalisation and industrial automation. This has caused interest rates to be ultra-low, and with a bit more rate-tweaking by the Reserve Bank, has allowed this mountain of debt to carry miniscule interest rates – though one does wonder where the refinance or repayment funding will come from when the principal falls due.

Ultra-low interest rates have coincided with a disposition towards higher savings, and consumption expenditure has declined. The effect of this is that Australian households, and the private sector generally, are in extremely strong financial position, which will lead to a consumption led economic surge in 2021 and 2022. In fact, household balance sheets, largely consisting of assets such as real estate and superannuation less mortgage and credit liabilities, have never been stronger.

After a prolonged drought agricultural conditions have improved dramatically, and this fortuitously coincided with a surge in agricultural commodity prices. Wheat for example, is now above US$6 per bushel, up from an average of US$4 to US$5 in recent years. NSW enjoyed a particularly large 2020 grain crop, about four times the drought affected 2019 harvest. This rare combination of high volumes and high prices will significantly bolster incomes and economics in rural and regional Australia. With surging farm incomes, and generous government asset depreciation incentives, John Deere dealers in regional towns would be well advised to have plenty of stock.

Australia continues to weather the pandemic and global downturn better than most, and with robust conditions in our core export sectors and higher household savings and wealth, our recovery and longer-term growth outlook is excellent. It is little wonder that share and real estate prices have been rising. Now, if only the COVID pandemic would come to an end!

Australian Shares

The Australian stock market, as measured by the S&P ASX200 Index, rose by a considerable 13.3% in the December quarter. For the 2020 year the market was down by just 1.5% which is a notable recovery considering the March 2020 quarter was negative 24%. Dividends were unusually low, about 2.9%, which reflected pandemic affected payout cuts and temporary regulatory restrictions on bank dividends. We expect cash dividends in 2021 to increase modestly, but the average yield to remain below 3%, due to the higher share prices.

In 2020 the energy, industrial, utilities, financials and property stock market sectors fell, all materially affected by pandemic economics and sentiment. However, in the December quarter bank, energy and property shares resurged, as the market rotated towards these economically cyclical or ‘value’ sectors. For context, Commonwealth Bank shares are currently about $85, having plumbed a low point of less than $55, albeit briefly, last March.

One of the standout features of 2020 was the price resilience, then price surge, of mineral and agricultural commodities, Australia’s primary exports. The doubling of the iron ore price led to strong share performance from industry participants like BHP, Rio Tinto, Fortescue and Mineral Resources, and has also underpinned a recovery in the Western Australian economy, bolstered the nations terms of trade, and caused the Australian dollar to rise. The price of coal also rose considerably, and just recently port supply chain constraints and blizzardy conditions in North Asia caused a dramatic increase in the spot price for liquified natural gas (LNG), our third largest export item.

Individual stock performance remained unusually unpredictable this last quarter. Very significant recoveries occurred in energy production and supply stocks Woodside and Santos, yet AGL shares, in the energy utility sector, declined. Bank shares rebounded strongly as loan default risks eased, BHP rose by about 20% on the back of higher commodity prices and agricultural stocks such as Costa rose due to better growing conditions. Healthcare shares, which have been stellar for several years underperformed, partly due to their fairly full prices and also the higher dollar, given that CSL, Ramsay and Sonic all have considerable overseas operations.

A major market feature is the reference ASX200 P/E ratio which (believe it or not) is currently 22.3x. However, this is a trailing data point, reflecting the significant decline in reported earnings per share (EPS) in 2020. Looking forward, there is forecast to be a 28% increase in average EPS post pandemic, which if attained would quickly revert the market average P/E ratio to the usual 16-17x, assuming no change to current share prices.

Consequently, market index forecasts of about 7200 points for the ASX200 are reasonable, assuming a reversion downwards in the P/E multiplier (caused by EPS recovery), a corresponding gradual, but not dramatic, uptrend in bond yields and the maintenance of the long-term average Equity Risk Premium (ERP), which allows an undemandingly low required market return (due to ultra-low bond yields).

A more bullish case would arise if the post pandemic EPS bounce happens whilst ten-year bond yields remain low, say below 1.5%. In this scenario the ASX200 would breach its previous high and head even higher.

The bearish case involves a stalling of EPS recovery due to constrained economics and a corresponding dislocation in the bond market should Central Banks either lose control of their monetary processes or choose to lessen their involvement. In this scenario share prices would fall sharply, though it is difficult to analytically justify an index below 6000 points for any sustained period.

Global Shares

International stock markets enjoyed strong gains in the December quarter, with the MSCI world index rising by 13.6%, in US dollar terms. Japan was the standout market, up 18.4% for the quarter as their industrial automation and consumer stocks surged. Excellent recovery was also experienced in Hong Kong shares (+16.1%), France (+15.6%), Singapore (+15.3%) and the USA (+11.7%).

Some of the price recovery can be attributed to stimulatory actions by the respective central banks, particularly the United States where a series of money-printing and borrowing programs were designed to support pandemic affected families and communities, and bolster confidence and activity. The United States’ bold and surprising experiment with a radically alternative style of President has mercifully ended, which has had a calming effect on markets and geopolitics globally.

Like Australia, overseas economic cyclical styled stocks generally outperformed in the December quarter, at the expense of the health and technology sectors, which are having a lull period after a few stellar years. However, as usual there has been considerable volatility on an individual stock basis. In our model portfolio US industrial General Electric and energy company Schlumberger both rose sharpy, as did financial service stocks BlackRock and Wells Fargo, and Japanese industrial automation stocks Nidec and Fanuc. European health stocks such as Roche, Sanofi and Novo Nordisk were a little weaker, as was Salesforce following their dilutive acquisition announcement of technology business Slack.

Most international stock markets now exhibit less favourable valuations than Australia, as their relative economic performance is weaker, and the pandemic effect more severe. However, unsurprisingly, our dollar has risen, which makes overseas shares a bit cheaper for Australian domiciled investors. Consequently, some foreign stocks are appealingly priced and have been added to our global portfolio. These include the Singaporean real estate company CapitaLand, and the British health/hygiene company Reckitt Benckiser, which counts Dettol, Mortein and Nurofen amongst its many brands.

The near-term outlook for the Australian dollar is bolstered by the strong volume and price conditions of our key exports, iron ore, coal, LNG and grains and cattle. Global supply chain constraints have generally helped Australian exports, but post pandemic de-bottlenecking will likely erode this advantage and cause the Australian dollar to stop rising.

Property Securities

The share prices of Australian Real Estate Investment Trusts (REIT’s) rose by 11.8% in the December quarter, consistent with the overall stock market. Many REITS traded ex their distributions in December, following which prices declined noticeably, reflecting investors primary appetite for yield, and a lack of faith in the intrinsic commercial real estate asset valuations.

An ongoing theme is the extent to which commercial office real estate will recover from last year’s low physical occupancy, and the accelerated trend to more flexible work locations. Dexus, a large landlord of CBD office properties, has suffered a considerable share price decline, but has not (yet) made material asset devaluations. The stock market, by pricing Dexus so low, is clearly expecting significant leasing stress ahead, particularly in the CBD office sector.

Meanwhile, suburban industrial and logistics real estate is booming, as a scramble for e-commerce distribution locations is forcing up rents and valuations. The favourable trend towards suburban and regional real estate, at the expense of CBD, will likely continue in 2021.

When inbound international tourism recommences and office demand outstrips supply again, the CBD will recover. However, in Sydney’s CBD new supply of more than 500,000sqm is looming in 2021-22 from developments currently under construction or refurbishment, to be followed by the completion of the Metro projects in 2023-24. A period of rising vacancy, a squeeze on rental income for landlords and juicy incentives for tenants is coming.

The specialist retail REIT’s have recovered considerably. Scentre Group, which owns the Westfield malls, has benefitted from a quick resurgence in suburban assets, despite some leasing difficulties with discretionary goods tenants, and low foot traffic in its CBD malls. The negativity of mid 2020 has proven to be overdone, however it is likely that pricing power has shifted markedly from the landlord to the tenant, meaning that growth in funds from operations, the key financial metric in REIT valuations, will be more difficult to achieve for some time.

Interest Rates

Whilst the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) maintains tight control over short term rates and medium-term bonds, a small rise in long-term interest rates, from about 0.8% in October to just above 1% suggests an economic turning point may have been reached. When bond yields rise the price of bonds falls, and longer duration exacerbates price movements. Hence, investors in fixed income securities need to consider pricing risks should an upward trend in rates occur.

In November the RBA reduced the cash interest rate to a historic low of just 0.1%. In its accompanying statement on monetary policy the RBA noted that whilst GDP was expected to increase by 5% in 2021 and 4% in 2022, it would only have reverted to end 2019 levels, far short of the pre-pandemic expectation. Moreover, the RBA is expecting an increase in the unemployment rate, to about 8%, in response to tightening eligibility for the JobKeeper and JobSeeker supplements, before reverting to about 6% by the end of 2022.

The RBA’s economic assessment led to their cash rate reduction decision, and they also added further significant stimulus by reducing the yield target for 3-year bonds to just 0.1%, reducing the interest rate on new Term Funding Facility drawings to 0.1%, and reducing the interest rate on exchange settlement balances to zero. Furthermore, they allocated $100m towards the purchase of 5-year to 10-year federal and state bonds in the first half of 2021, the significance of which is important, as it indicates a preparedness to maintain aggressive interest policy for an extended period.

The RBA has made it clear that they are not contemplating further interest rate reductions and will not consider a policy of negative interest rates due its questionable benefit. They have made it abundantly clear that their policy of ultra-low rates will persist for a few years, which should maintain a stimulatory tailwind to economic activity recovery.

Low cash rates mean term deposit interest will be similarly miserly. Banks don’t need significant funding from customers when the RBA is providing it more cheaply, so interest-seeking investors will regrettably have to suffer an income hit for an extended period.

Credit spreads and yields generally on higher risk fixed income securities have been surprisingly stable, reflecting very little delinquency or default expectation. Indeed, credit markets are remarkably calm, perhaps too calm, as some lingering economic effects of last years’ turmoil are still to play out. Hybrid prices in Australia are relatively high, reflecting a stronger outlook for domestic bank financial stability, but remain one of the few areas where a 2% to 3% cash income yield is still available.

Outlook

Some of the uncertainties of late 2020 have eased, paving the way for a recovery in share and real estate prices, and a more optimistic outlook for 2021, though economic activity this year will need to contend with the timing and extent of stimulus winddowns, and stubbornly elevated unemployment. Consumer and business confidence, and consequential consumption and business activity, should improve as the rollout of COVID vaccines become more widespread.

Interest rates will remain historically low, but the cycle may at last have bottomed, placing the risks associated with rising bond yields and a resurgence in inflation more firmly on the valuation agenda.

In this environment, share markets should find higher ground, but the pathway this year is likely to be to beset by two or three periods of elevated volatility, of the 5% to 10% type, so less severe than last year. Such market movements should provide investors with opportunities to purchase shares at appealing prices.


Yours sincerely,

Malcolm Palmer
Joseph Palmer & Sons

Disclaimer General Advice Warning

This publication has been prepared by Joseph Palmer Sons (ABN 29 548 490 818) an Australian Financial Services Licensee (AFSL 247067). Whilst the information contained in this publication has been prepared with all reasonable care from sources, which Joseph Palmer Sons believes are reliable, no responsibility or liability is accepted by Joseph Palmer Sons for any errors or omissions or misstatements however caused. Any opinions, forecasts or recommendations reflects the judgment and assumptions of Joseph Palmer Sons as at the date of publication and may change without notice. Joseph Palmer Sons, their officers, agents and employees exclude all liability whatsoever, in negligence or otherwise, for any loss or damage relating to this document to the full extent permitted by law. This publication is not and should not be construed as an offer to sell or the solicitation of an offer to purchase or subscribe for any investment. Any securities recommendation contained in this publication is unsolicited general information only. Joseph Palmer Sons are not aware that any recipient intends to rely on this publication and are not aware of the manner in which a recipient intends to use it. In preparing our information, it is not possible to take into consideration the investment objectives, financial situation or particular needs of any individual recipient. Investors must obtain individual financial advice from their investment advisor to determine whether recommendations contained in this publication are appropriate to their personal investment objectives, financial situation or particular needs before acting on any such recommendations.

Show All

Full name*
Email*
Phone number*
Message*
.
Slide To Submit
»
Please fill out the form and slide to submit